RAW List (Re-Posted)

[P0ke N Die]

Before you start reading, here's the TL;DR for people who don't have enough time to read...

 

Bring PCR list back, with F2P+P2P PCR list, make it so you can only declare on clans 2 spaces above you to prevent people at the bottom declaring on people at the top to troll. Remove clans who decline 3 wars in a row.

 

And if you want to investigate the idea properly, read on...

 

 

===========================

 

 

Now to start this topic off, if you are one of the bandwagon idiots who think that the PCR list will fail because somebody posted that on Pure Warfare even though you weren't around when it existed, get off the topic. Either post a reasonable argument or go and pretend to be intelligent elsewhere. I'm not writing this topic for trolls.

 

 

===========================

 

 

We're all a part of a pure world with all talk and no walk. The community is growing stale and instead of fighting it out on the battlefield to prove something, people resort to smack-talking and then excuses. Although I am a lover of the wilderness myself, the only place to settle a good brawl such as a PCR war is in Clan Wars where no outside circumstances can change anything.

 

So, what was the problem with the original PCR list?

 

• Clans at the bottom would declare against clans at the top to troll.
  
• Clans would go inactive/decline every fight.
  

 

I believe that there are viable solutions to these problems that would allow the PCR list to function correctly and possibly bring the spark back to this community. I used the PCR list quite frequently when it was around, declaring and winning three wars. So let's start with the basics just so that we can move onto the new rules...

 

===========================

 

Rules

• 20 Defence Cap.
  
• All On.
  
• Clan Wars Dangerous.
  
• Three Rounds.
  
• Two Classic, One Plat.
  
• 5 Days Prep Minimum.
  
• Declarations to be accepted in 24 Hours.
  
• Memberlist locked 24 hours after declaration.
  
• Clans can be declared on once every two weeks.
  
• If site is hacked, clans have two weeks to recover.
  

 

Just incase you did forget, above are the pretty basic rules of a PCR war. A clan will declare on a clan with a higher position with the following rules and will then take the spot of the clan they declare on if they win. If the clan declines the war, they will be removed from the PCR list. Simple!

 

===========================

 

Lower clans declaring on higher

 

Correct me if I'm mistaken but I remember a really small clan declaring for the #1 spot and wasting the time of the #1 clan, this is when people started to view the PCR list as a joke. Well there is a really simple solution to this, you make it a rule that you can not declare on a clan more than two positions ahead of you. For example, if you are currently #7, you can only declare for #6 or #5. Many of the current rivalries are three way (Such as MM, FOE and EOP) so having to move up one step at a time might reduce the action.

 

I believe that if we implemented this, people would not be able to exploit the "Decline and move down" rule.

 

===========================

 

Clans Frequently Declining

 

So another problem with the old list was people making excuses and declining wars. Well the first real solution to this is, grow some ******* balls and stop taking RuneScape too seriously. Honestly it's a game, and if clan leaders are willing to deprive action from their own members just to protect their own reputation then I feel sorry for their clan.

 

But on a serious note, there should be an inactivity rule for the PCR list. If you decline three PCR declarations in a row, you should be moved to the bottom of the PCR list or possibly kicked off it. People will probably try and ride one rank (Getting #3 and then declining a war every two weeks) and so having an inactivity rule should fix that.

 

===========================

 

To be honest, a PCR list is what we really need. I can see a lot of peaks during the summer, clans are getting their old-school members back and there are so many new and upcoming clans. If we are able to find somebody civil enough to manage this with enough free time, it would be worth it. Please post your opinions and suggestions.

[Lawson]

Good post, I think it could work if the 2 factors you stated from the old PCR list are changed on the new one.

 

Support.

[Iraqi Mage]

It should be 1 def cap tbh.

[Biohazard]

If you want it, you do it.

[RIP Sizzy]

It should be 1 def cap tbh.

why?

[`Pure]

It should be 1 def cap tbh.

good luck convincing all the clans to do that. although i would be all for it.

[Lawson]

It should be 1 def cap tbh.

[AndyIbeat]

If this was to happen, rules should be flexible to what the clans want.

[Altus]

1 defence cap and yes, would be nice to bring it back (:

[L Ghostly Pk]

Yeah, it should be 1 def cap

 

Support,

 

:)

[Mafia]

Lol no

[Kyle]

tl;dr

 

as i was scrolling down here to post that i saw the rules

 

 

no way lmfao

[Blitz U]

Agreed, would be fun.

[BIGRYAN]

1 Def for real pures.

[Guthix]

20 def - no

clan wars - 100+ pulls are the norm now

[Ivp]

10 def cap really is the most logical.

 

Like I said, its a great idea.

[Inu]

10 defense seems the most logical

[badger]

10 defence at the most in my opinion.

[Derp]

nah.

[Scotts Law]

10 def seems fair

[Hi Im Taka]

Quit being such a *****. 1def cap

[Nicholas]

i say 39 def cap

[BigBob]

10 def cap is a good compromise.

[Great]

lest do thiw PCR back

[trolledxd]

if clans allow 20def then 20 def should be a rule.

Cases with MM and other clans that thier majority of their ML 10def- thats what you have to risk to be the REAL NUMBER 1 PURE CLAN LEFT