why always matched?

[WillT]

preps used to be non matched, which was fun, if a clan didn't pull much they had to deal with it. Now, everything is matched. Some say its fairer, but not really, considering some clans will just bring their top 20ish, then another clan will bring 30+ all of their members, which disadvantages that clan, for example. DP will pull around 40-50 to a fullout prep, but only 30 ish of their top levels to a matched prep. So is it really a fair fight? I don't think so.

[Ded]

Who cares...

[WillT]

bump:)

[Sean®]

!ml DP

 

We don't PM certain people to come, if someone wants to come they can come..

[WillT]

Not sure if srs ray

[Drunk]

Because if one clan has a really nice pull the point of the fight is ruined. I would expect any clan to win being +10 in f2p. Its just to not only depend on the pull but skill and levels as well.

[Toby]

Because if one clan has a really nice pull the point of the fight is ruined. I would expect any clan to win being +10 in f2p. Its just to not only depend on the pull but skill and levels as well.

^

[WillT]

Walli and zer0, no offence but your logic is retarded, either that or you havnt thought anything through.

 

In a matched opt fight, IR will always bring EVERYONE, and pull more than the opposing clan. Yet on trips, we are outnumbered, I wander why? Anyone my point is that IR end up having to sit 5-10 people, is that action? no, it isnt.

[WillT]

Yes drunk, I understand but thats why people get preps with clans that have a similar number of people on. Back in the day, it was rare that one clan would pull 40 vs a clan that pulled 20, it was more or less the same amount of people

[Sniping]

Way to be modest Walli. Drunk hit the nail on the head.

[Lawson]

Because if one clan has a really nice pull the point of the fight is ruined. I would expect any clan to win being +10 in f2p. Its just to not only depend on the pull but skill and levels as well.

 

this

[Target]

i don't know why, but very good question.

[Drunk]

rofl... poor you and ir.

 

Try sitting at least 20+ people every prep we get.

 

If we didnt do matched would be easy win as runescape these days is all about opts and its hard enough to find a clan to fight at times anyway.

 

You asked why we do matched and i answered.

If your going to complain about sitting 20 people then I suggest you just fight clans with your sized Memberlist such as Fi and MM. But the reality is if you weren't currently the clan pulling the big numbers, you wouldn't have that point of view that you have right now.

[walli]

If your going to complain about sitting 20 people then I suggest you just fight clans with your sized Memberlist such as Fi and MM. But the reality is if you weren't currently the clan pulling the big numbers, you wouldn't have that point of view that you have right now.

 

 

lol... no ****.

 

MM and Fi rarely prep us, we do try.

 

I dont get what you are saying... how could it change? If we pulled less than every1 else than we would still say the winner is the person with more opts as is the case in 97% of fights.

 

Only difference is we may actually find more people willing to fight us regularly..

 

so i still dont get what this point of view is or how it is meant to change :O

[Davvvvid]

Because foe would always win and nobody likes that. Also would mean none of you would fight us so i dont give as **** so long as action comes my way.

 

man speaks the truth

[-Charlie-]

Well it's not always matched lol, depends on what each clan want.

 

But IMO, matched is just so the war isn't determined by numbers, more of skill and organization

[True Whip]

Challenge FOE non matched, and that'll be a reminder of why everyone challenges with matched.

Not trying to sound cocky, but there's the truth.

It ****** me off though, when clans would only bring their higher levels or whatever, so I like the minimum opts for a fight thing.

Means we don't have to sit so many.

[WillT]

Well it's not always matched lol, depends on what each clan want.

 

But IMO, matched is just so the war isn't determined by numbers, more of skill and organization

 

If a clan has a fullout, and they both do the best to pull the highest amount possible, and they both end up pulling the same amount, say 40vs40, then yes, that determines Quality rather than quantity, but if a clan tells all their low lv/in experienced members not to come, and the other clan lets all their members come, that does not measure quality.

[Sniping]

So the argument here is that in matched fights, clans sit their low levels and only let their "good" people compete?

[Waldo]

So the argument here is that in matched fights, clans sit their low levels and only let their "good" people compete?

Which is stupid because if clans wouldn't let lower levels war, then the lower levels would leave.

[0ynxx]

No...

http://rs-fi.com/index.php?showtopic=28311

your getting owned by everyone in this topic

[walli]

why start a topic and then turn it into a flame fest because somebody replies with something you dont like.

 

pointless.

 

Topic is over and plenty of answers for you to go off.

[WillT]

Which is stupid because if clans wouldn't let lower levels war, then the lower levels would leave.

 

Clans do it, last year DP fought IR in a p2p matched opts fight. They pulled 20 of their highest levels on the ML, while their lower levels watched from the portal. IR pulled 36, we beat them 2-1.

[Davvvvid]

ehh

[Anthoni]

Closed.